Update, October 27, 2026: Judge Sharon L. Gleason’s October 26 order granted expedited consideration of motions by proposed intervenors in United States v. State of Alaska, case 3:26-cv-00376-SLG. The order addresses procedure; it does not grant the DOJ’s requested certification block or resolve the merits.
Read the October 26 court order.
Archive scope: The original October 23 report follows, with the voting explanation and procedural status corrected.
President Donald Trump said Friday that he was the one who directed the Justice Department to sue Alaska over its upcoming U.S. Senate election, an extraordinary admission of federal interference in a state race that could decide control of the Senate.
“Well, I’m the one that said ‘do it,’” Trump told reporters in Florida on Friday when asked about the lawsuit, which targets a second candidate on the Alaska ballot who shares the incumbent senator’s name.
The Justice Department filed the suit on Thursday in federal court in Anchorage, asking a judge to preemptively block Alaska from certifying its Senate results if the Republican incumbent loses by a narrow margin. The DOJ claims voters could be confused by two nearly identical names on the November 3 ballot, in a race Democrats hope to flip.
What the DOJ lawsuit asks the court to do
The lawsuit focuses on Dan J. Sullivan Jr., a second candidate who will appear on the general election ballot without a party designation, alongside incumbent Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan and Democratic challenger Mary Peltola, a former U.S. representative.
The department alleges that Daniel J. Sullivan is running “with the intention of misleading supporters of Senator Sullivan into voting for him,” and asks the court to block certification of an outcome “that may be impacted by voter confusion,” so there can be “an investigation to determine whether votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan were meant to be cast for Senator Sullivan.”
A DOJ spokesperson said the agency is taking “necessary steps to ensure that this frivolous candidacy does not undermine the integrity of Alaska’s election or the will of its voters.” The suit leans on the preface of a federal voter-registration law that protects the “integrity of the electoral process,” claiming the United States “suffers an injury when the certification of the election for a federal office is tainted by a frivolous candidacy.”
Why two Dan Sullivans are on the ballot
The challenger is a former U.S. Forest Service worker and elementary school teacher who filed to run on May 29, seeking to unseat the senator and “put Alaska first,” according to his campaign website, which advertised “Dan Sullivan Challenges Dan Sullivan for US Senate Seat.” He has denied in interviews that his aim is to confuse voters.
The ballot itself distinguishes the two men: the incumbent is listed as “Registered Republican” and “incumbent,” while Dan J. Sullivan appears with his middle initial and no party designation. In the primary, the incumbent won 68,726 votes to the challenger’s 4,107. Alaska’s Division of Elections had removed Dan J. Sullivan from the ballot after determining his candidacy was intended to mislead voters, but the Alaska Supreme Court ruled in June that he should be included.
How Alaska’s ranked-choice system affects the case
Alaska advances the top four primary candidates to the general election regardless of party, and voters rank candidates by preference. If no candidate gets a majority of first-choice votes, the lowest vote-getter is eliminated and their votes are reallocated round by round until someone wins.
The DOJ alleges voters backing the incumbent might not rank him at all, or might rank Daniel J. Sullivan above him, so the challenger’s votes could flow to the Democrat. “Even if a majority of Alaskans wish to vote for Senator Sullivan, Daniel J. Sullivan’s presence on the ballot will result in a victory for Peltola,” the lawsuit states. Rank order matters: under Alaska’s system, a ballot counts for the highest-ranked continuing candidate. If that candidate is eliminated, it can transfer to the next available preference. Ranking the two candidates in either order is not necessarily equivalent.
Alaska expects ranked-choice tabulation to begin on November 18, more than two weeks after Election Day, following the deadline for overseas ballots. The case has been assigned to Judge Sharon L. Gleason, who was appointed by President Barack Obama, as reported on October 23. A later procedural order is described in the update above.
Legal experts dismiss the DOJ’s theory
Election law experts have panned the lawsuit, calling it a publicity stunt seeking relief no federal law allows. The suit is based on a “strange and unusual” legal theory, said Derek Muller, an election law professor at Notre Dame Law School, who wrote that “the legal argument is one of the worst ones I’ve ever seen” and is “designed to win the press release rather than the litigation.”
Trump’s administration “has absolutely no authority to tell Alaska when or how to certify the results of its Senate election,” said David Becker of the Center for Election Innovation and Research, adding that “this issue has already been fully litigated by Alaska’s courts.” Vanita Gupta, an associate U.S. attorney general during the Biden administration, called the suit “meritless,” while former RNC counsel Ben Ginsberg said, “There is not a rational legal reason to do it.”

Trump’s admission and the political fallout
The lawsuit highlights the apparent willingness of Trump’s administration to contest the results of the November 3 midterm elections. The administration has taken an increasingly aggressive approach to election oversight, pressing states for voter-registration data and arguing stricter measures are needed for public confidence. Critics, including Democratic and some Republican election officials, view the moves as federal overreach.
The Alaska race is one Democrats hope to flip: Sen. Dan S. Sullivan faces Peltola in a close contest, and Democrats need to net four seats in November to win the Senate. Polling has shown Peltola tied or slightly ahead in a state Trump carried by some 14 percentage points in 2024. Peltola spokesperson Harry Child called the suit “a despicable political threat to overturn an election,” while Sullivan spokesman Nate Adams said the incumbent will “let the DOJ complaint run its course.”

Why it matters
The Justice Department is asking a federal judge to delay or block certification of a Senate election before any votes are counted — relief that election law experts say they have never seen attempted. Alaska election officials already “went out of their way” to reduce confusion with middle initials, an incumbent label, and no party designation for the challenger. Ginsberg noted the case, like a recent DOJ suit over California ballots, was filed by a political appointee’s office in Washington that does not normally handle this litigation.

Procedural status
The October 26 order grants expedited consideration of proposed intervenors’ motions. It sets briefing steps and does not decide whether the DOJ is entitled to block certification. A procedural timetable must not be reported as a judgment on the merits.
Key Takeaways
- The Justice Department sued Alaska on Thursday, asking a federal judge to preemptively block certification of the state’s U.S. Senate race if Sen. Dan Sullivan loses, citing voter confusion over a second candidate named Dan J. Sullivan.
- Trump admitted Friday that he personally directed the lawsuit: “Well, I’m the one that said ‘do it,’” he told reporters in Florida.
- Election law experts, including Notre Dame’s Derek Muller and former RNC counsel Ben Ginsberg, say the legal theory is unprecedented and unlikely to survive in court.
- The race pits incumbent Republican Dan S. Sullivan against Democrat Mary Peltola under Alaska’s ranked-choice system, and could help decide control of the U.S. Senate.
Editorial correction, October 27, 2026: Added the subsequent court order, distinguished procedure and expert predictions from a merits decision, and corrected the suggestion that ranking candidates in either order is equivalent.
Sources
Alaska Division of Elections: ranked-choice voting.
- Reuters: “US Justice Dept sues to block possible Alaska election of Democrat to Senate”
- CNN: “Trump DOJ sues to block Alaska US Senate results if Republican incumbent loses”
- Related GlobalDeskNews coverage: Trump Cuts Canada Tariffs in Election-Week Boost for Collins; Trump Threatens ‘Another Little Epic Fury’ Strike on Iran; Trump Denies US Strike on Iran This Weekend After Envoy Claim
By GlobalDeskNews Staff
